HomeProjectCosts

DIY vs Hiring a Contractor

Know when to grab your tools and when to call the pros. Making the right choice saves money and prevents costly mistakes.

The DIY Decision Framework

1

Does it require a permit?

If yes, check if DIY permits are allowed in your area. Some jurisdictions require licensed contractors for permitted work.

2

Is there a safety risk?

Electrical, gas, structural, and roofing work carry significant safety risks that often outweigh potential savings.

3

Do you have the skills?

Be honest about your abilities. Watching YouTube videos isn't the same as hands-on experience.

4

Do you have the time?

DIY projects often take 2-3x longer than professional work. Is your time worth the savings?

5

What's the cost of failure?

If a mistake could cost more to fix than the original project, consider hiring a pro.

DIY-Friendly Projects

These projects are generally safe for motivated DIYers with basic skills.

Painting Interior Walls

Easy
Potential Savings:60-70%
Time Required:1-3 days per room

Proper prep work (filling holes, taping, priming) is key to professional results.

Installing Laminate Flooring

Moderate
Potential Savings:50-60%
Time Required:1-2 days per 200 sq ft

Click-lock systems are DIY-friendly. Hardwood nailing requires more skill.

Replacing Light Fixtures

Easy
Potential Savings:70-80%
Time Required:30 min - 1 hour each

Always turn off power at the breaker. Match wire colors carefully.

Installing a Toilet

Moderate
Potential Savings:50-70%
Time Required:2-3 hours

Use a new wax ring. Tighten bolts evenly to avoid cracking the porcelain.

Basic Landscaping

Easy-Moderate
Potential Savings:50-80%
Time Required:Varies

Start small. Consider drainage and sunlight when planting.

Assembling & Installing Cabinets

Moderate-Hard
Potential Savings:40-50%
Time Required:1-2 days

Level and plumb are critical. Use a laser level for best results.

Always Hire a Professional

These projects involve significant safety, legal, or complexity concerns.

Electrical Panel Upgrades

Why hire: Safety & Code

High - Fire/electrocution risk. Permits and inspections required.

Major Plumbing Work

Why hire: Complexity & Code

High - Water damage, mold risk. Often requires permits.

Structural Changes

Why hire: Safety & Engineering

Very High - Load-bearing walls require engineering approval.

Roof Replacement

Why hire: Safety & Warranty

High - Fall risk. DIY installation voids most material warranties.

HVAC Installation

Why hire: Code & Efficiency

High - Improper installation affects efficiency and lifespan.

Gas Line Work

Why hire: Safety & Legal

Extreme - Gas leaks can be fatal. Licensed work often required by law.

Recommended DIY Resource

DIY Home Repair and Improvement Bible

The ultimate guide for homeowners tackling DIY projects. This comprehensive resource covers everything from basic repairs to major improvements, with step-by-step instructions and professional tips.

View on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps support our free calculators and guides.

The True Cost of DIY

Hidden DIY Costs

  • - Tool purchases or rentals
  • - Material waste from inexperience (often 10-20% more)
  • - Time away from work or family
  • - Cost to fix mistakes
  • - Potential warranty issues on materials

When DIY Makes Sense

  • + Low-risk, reversible projects
  • + You genuinely enjoy the work
  • + You have the time and patience
  • + Labor costs make up most of the project cost
  • + You want to learn a new skill